Pondering a 2015 Cubs Contender

Pondering a 2015 Cubs Contender

Anno wrote a blog on our mother ship today that was thought-provoking.  That’s kind of a nice way for me to say he’s a bit nuts without getting fired, but there’s a rational explanation for his madness too.  Now I know that it is premature to put all our hopes in the Cubs’ farmhands, but they’re pretty good and it’s hard to not be optimistic.  And I’ve already outlined the Cubs’ budget situation and the likely free agents they’ll target.  I can’t guarantee anything (there are no guarantees in baseball) but I don’t think it’s out there to suggest that the Cubs could contend for at least a wild card spot next season.

Take Jon Lester, for example.  He’s having a good year and was recently traded to Oakland, which means that all it will cost the Cubs now is some money.  The Cubs seem to be okay with taking on money which is why, if the rumors are true, they decided to put a claim in on Cole Hamels.  I am not as confident as Anno that a trade makes sense now, but with the aforementioned awesome farm full of awesome, there could be some exciting movement this offseason, depending on whether the Cubs want to part with their guys for Hamels’ (or some other ace-level pitcher with cost certainty and/or club control).  After all, there were various reasons NOT to try to trade for David Price, who eventually went to the Tigers for a return that wasn’t exactly spectacular.  So we could be looking at a rotation headlined by Lester, Hamels (or equivalent), Jake Arrieta and with a large number of option to bring up the rear including Kyle Hendricks plus the claim of Jacob Turner if that trade/claim is finalized.  Even if the Cubs don’t trade for Hamels (or similar), the rotation still looks solid.

The call-up of Javier Baez signaled a big change in the organizational philosophy from “acquire all the talent” to “let’s see what we got” as they continue the transition towards contention.  The idea seems to be to let Javy (and Arismendy Alcantara) take their lumps in a year that no longer matters from a contention standpoint, but this will be important for their development and you’d rather they slump and learn without as much pressure.  We’re also waiting on the expected September call-up of Jorge Soler, and probably Kris Bryant‘s debut in late-April next year.  The Cubs also seem very interested in a potentially MLB ready Cuban outfielder that they have the money to sign, an option that only costs money and not a draft pick.

Let’s play armchair GM and fantasize about a roster next year:


C – Welington Castillo

1B – Anthony Rizzo

2B – Javier Baez

SS – Starlin Castro

3B – Luis Valbuena (until end of April)/Kris Bryant (upon debut)

LF – Chris Coghlan/Justin Ruggiano platoon

CF – Arismendy Alcantara or Rusney Castillo (Alcantara can also be 2B or utility guy)

RF – Jorge Soler


Jon Lester

Cole Hamels (or equivalent)

Jake Arrieta

Kyle Hendricks

Travis Wood, Tsuyoshi Wada, Neil Ramirez (if stretched), etc etc etc OMG OPTIONS


Neil Ramirez

Pedro Strop

Hector Rondon

Armando Rivero

Arodys Vizcaino

Power arm after power arm after power arm…


I mean, it does look good, doesn’t it?  This hypothetical roster needs to be filled out some more but even with some bumps and stumbles along the way, it seems competitive to me.  Maybe they even make it into the postseason a year or two earlier than expected.  Maybe we’ll get to strut a little earlier.  It’s fun to dream.

Please subscribe to our blogs (info here) and follow us on Facebook and Twitter!


Leave a comment
  • fb_avatar

    If they don't have use him in a trade for pitching Addison Russell should be up next year as well, probably mid season. Then you have decisions to make. Also if you're using Alcantara off the bench you're doing it wrong. This kid has defied expectations at every level.

  • In reply to TC421:

    I think if Alcantara is off the bench, something is going right because that means there are a lot of spots being filled up by guys better than Alcantara, which is kind of scary if you think about it. But I think Alcantara is the Opening Day CF.

  • Expect veteran acquisitions. Why not add a veteran behind the plate like Russell Martin (or Kurt Suzuki via trade)? The going rate for top veteran catchers is 2 years at $15 million combined. That's what Martin got two years ago, and Saltalamachia last year. You can also easily upgrade that left-field platoon with a Gary Matthews style trade to get the clubhouse leadership necessary to guide the team in a pennant race.

    I also foresee Castro being moved for starting pitching, so I can envision a veteran at SS or 2B until Addison Russell is ready. But that is only if you are trying to compete in 2015. If not taking a stab at post-season in 2015, then you give time to Alcantara and Baez at SS/2B (assuming Castro is moved). But this also would limit your attractiveness to get a top free agent pitcher, who like Takada last year won't be overly interested in patiently waiting for unproven prospects to mature and pay off.

  • In reply to SkitSketchJeff:

    I explored the veteran catcher aspect in the previous blogged linked in this article re: free agency speculation :-)

Leave a comment