Illinois vs. Florida in the COVID derby. And the clear winner is...

If Illinois restaurant owner Jeff Buckler wanted to keep Lil Buford's Bar & Grill open during the COVIDI-19 pandemic, he would be more than welcome to open it here in Jacksonville, Florida.

Instead, Illinois’ strict lockdown dictates demand that he close in-door dining, an option that that would destroy his Champaign County, Illinois restaurant and throw his employees out of work. So, in defiance, he has vowed to keep the restaurant open until he receives a court order to shut it down.

So, c'mon down, Jeff. Here inner dining--with proper protections--is humming.  Not only are  restaurants are open in Jacksonville. Schools are too. Disney World is. The NFL Jacksonville Jaguars play before fans. The Jacksonville Symphony Orchestra is live in front of an audience. Uncounted  small businesses have not gone bankrupt.

Yet, Florida and  Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis  continue to be maligned from out-of-state know-it-alls for supposedly putting us poor Floridians in mortal danger. I've heard DiSantis called "criminal" and worse.

Therefore, I return to comparing the deaths rate in Florida and Illinois. And the results are the same when I began digging up the facts last spring in response to the  tsk-tsking of Florida by Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot and other scolds.  That fact was that us-uns in Florida are better off than you-uns in Illinois.*

I'll start with the COVID-19 death rate--the most reliable and relevant of the flood of statistics that are drowning us.

The COVID-19 cumulative death rate in Florida is 99 per 100,000 population. In Illinois, it is 137 per 100,000 population. That’s about a third more deaths in Illinois per 100,00 than in Florida. In the past week or so, the average death rate per 100,000 in Florida was 0.4 percent. In Illinois, it is 1.1 percent.  In absolute numbers, Florida has more deaths (21,308) than Illinois (17,470), but that’s because Florida’s population (21.7 million) is almost double Illinois’  (12.7 and shrinking).

Hospitalizations and more serious infections of course are grave matters, yet--unfortunately--comparable figures are unavailable for the two states. The least important statistic, but the one that gets the most attention, is the number of cases. The number from state to state is  so squishy as to be useless. Yet, they continue to be the almost singular focus of the media.

While the comparisons between Florida and Illinois are interesting in themselves, they take on more importance in the continuing debate over the most effective method of preventing the spread of the novel coronavirus.

To open or close the economy? Strict sheltering at home or more of the blessings of liberty. Governors and mayors who demand rigid restrictions on occupations, schools and travel should have another think coming if they would examine how shut states such as Illinois compare with more open ones like Florida's.

Florida does better than the given wisdom; it was supposed to do worse than restrictive states like Illinois--much worse if you listen to the most vocal critics. Obviously staying open is not in itself an explanation for the better health of Florida; it only addresses the claim that staying open is a death warrant.

But one thing for sure: Florida is the more livable state, one in which children are getting better education by attending schools, small business are on a more solid footing and, dare I say it, people are living healthier and happier lives.

Note: I didn't start this competition. It began last spring as a response Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot butted into Florida's business with heavy criticism. Here are my responses:

*The statistics cited are from the Centers for Disease Control and the COVID Tracking Project.

To subscribe to the Barbershop, type your email Address the address s in the box and click the "create subscription" button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.


Leave a comment
  • I know that you do not like receiving opinions which differ from yours, but I would urge you to look at the dynamic of this current pandemic. Maps in newspapers, such as the New York Times and the Washington Post show the coronavirus moving out of the northern Midwest into first the Middle South and now into the Southeast. Tennessee, Alabama and Georgia are being hit hard, and it is now moving into northern Florida. I see that in Duval County the rate of new cases is now 64 per 100,000, while in Cook County it is down to 38. Deaths follow infections by about two weeks. Before this is over, citizens of your county may also wonder if steps can be taken to minimize the death and suffering.

  • In reply to jnorto:

    I don't mind differing opinions. I do mind insult and nonsense.

Leave a comment

  • Advertisement:
  • Advertisement:
  • ChicagoNow is full of win

    Welcome to ChicagoNow.

    Meet our bloggers,
    post comments, or
    pitch your blog idea.

  • Visit my new website

    I'm a freelance writer, editor and author. I can help you with a wide variety of projects. Check out my new website at

  • Subscribe to The Barbershop

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Dennis Byrne’s Facebook Fan Page

  • Like me on Facebook

  • Our National Debt

  • Twitter

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

  • /Users/dennisby/Desktop/trailer.mp4
  • Advertisement: