Cubs 2015 playoffs -- we saw the best of games; we saw the worst of games

A few weeks ago Son of Admin (SoA) urged us all to register with the Cubs so that one or more of us might have the chance to purchase playoff tickets. So we all went online, from Brooklyn to Indianapolis to Wicker Park, and filled in the form.

SoA won for the National League Division Series; I (Admin) and Wife of Admin (WoA) won for the League Championship Series. We were able to purchase tickets for both NLDS games at Wrigley Field, and the first two of three scheduled NLCS games. (Could this be why the Cubs were swept in four games? Because we didn't have tickets for Game Five???)

As I've already written, Games Three and Four of the NLDS were two of the best games we have ever attended.

NLDS Game Four

NLDS Game Four

(Admin note: Little did I know that the above-pictured scorecard would be my last of the year. For the NLCS the Cubs didn't print the traditional $1.50 scorecard but tried to force fans to spend 10 times that amount, or $15, on a glorified "souvenir" magazine that included scorecards. Not in our budget. [Could this be why the Cubs were swept in four games? Because the baseball gods wanted to punish the greedy Cubs business guys by making them eat at least 1/3 of the magazine's print run because only two out of three games were played???])

Games Three and Four of the NLCS were two of the most painful games we have ever attended.

Fans watch the last pitch of the NLCS. Note the range of emotions from the fearful young woman at left to the always hopeful kids on the right.

Bleak house. Fans watch the last pitch of the NLCS. Note the range of emotions from the fearful young woman at left to the always hopeful kids on the right.

Much has been written online and in the national press about the Cubs' collapse. From this fan's point of view, it felt inevitable from the moment Jake Arrieta's first pitch last Sunday sailed past catcher Miguel Montero on its flight to the backstop.

That old feeling came back. You know the one. It's the feeling we got in the pits of our stomachs in 1984 when Leon Durham booted a routine ground ball during the playoffs against San Diego.  Or in 2003, not when Steve Bartman reached for a foul ball, but when Mark Prior came off the mound looking for a fan interference call while Moises Alou threw a fit with his mitt. Or the feeling in 2008 when Ryan Dempster started walking lots of Dodgers. None of those games were over, by any means. But that feeling of dread crept into our blood and took over until the last Cub out of those playoffs series sealed their doom yet again.

Younger fans say, NO! You gotta believe and be optimistic no matter what! ... and I agree with them, but we just can't. The feeling takes hold and won't let go.

In Game Three of this year's NLCS when the lead run scored on a strike out that should have ended the inning, we knew that lead run would turn out to be the winning run. We just knew it.

But we hope. For each of those incidents we hoped like heck that the feeling was wrong. That Arrieta would right himself. That Montero would chase down the ball and throw Conforto out at first, even as we could plainly see that the ball had rolled too far away for that to happen. Just as we hoped that even after being humiliated in Game Six of the 2003 NLCS, the Cubs would win Game Seven. They would have Kerry Wood on the mound, after all.

Much has been written about what a wonderful season 2015 was for the Cubs and Cub fans. And it was. John Arguello at Cubs Den summarized the year better than most. Much has also been written about how this is only the beginning, that this young Cub team defied all the predictions and turned expectations for perhaps a .500 season into an improbable, celebratory 97-win year. From no expectations to great expectations as, after winning the NLDS, the Cubs were actually favorites to win the World Series as of October 14. (Kiss of death. Is this why the Cubs were swept in the NLCS??? Something like Prior and Wood on the cover of Sports Illustrated in 2003?)

But what makes me sick is not the fact that the Cubs lost, but that they lost in a way that supports the ongoing Cubs stereotype of a team that always, ultimately goes down to defeat tragically. Sadly. With a dropped third strike or a booted grounder to first, or shortstop, or a parcel of walks and a grand slam served up by the Cubs' ace, or putting in a fastball pitcher to pitch to a scorchingly hot fastball hitter who then promptly delivers a single to score the eventual winning runs (1989, Mitch Williams vs. Will Clark).

There's a term I've heard and read often to describe the Cubs' downfall this year. Sad. Does any other professional sports franchise have that word associated with it so strongly?

I'm sick of sad. I'm sick of lovable. I want the Cubs to be hated like the Yankees. And here's where hope comes back into play. I hope that all the baseball pundits are right about this team. That this is only the beginning. That these young Cubs will grow into a ferocious group that takes no prisoners. That the great expectations for the future are surpassed, just as the modest expectations for this year became great.

Now that's a term I want to see associated with the Cubs from 2016 until ... well, until forever. Great. How about the Great Chicago Cubs? Let some other franchise become lovable losers. Like the Cardinals. Or the Yankees.
Want to read more Waiting4Cubs? Click here and scroll down through the entire collection of blogs.

Want to be notified when a new blog is posted? Type your email address in the box and click the "create subscription" button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.

Filed under: Uncategorized


Leave a comment
  • My view is that you got 4 more home games than would have been predicted 4 months ago, so that's o.k.

    The Cubs will get Yankee hate only if they dominate by hiring a bunch of roided up players, sort of if the whole team were A Roid and Sam Me.

  • In reply to jack:

    It was more than o.k. It was fantastic to go to those four games. Totally unexpected (I think I predicted the Cubs to win something like 80 games!).

    Regarding the Yankees, they were hated long before steroids were available, if I remember correctly.

    Thanks, Jack!

  • 10 teams make the playoffs and 9 of them lose their final game. It's cruel but true. If the Cubs make the playoffs regularly over the next decade they are usually going to be one of those nine teams. This is something we have to come to grips with as a fan base.

    I struggle to find sadness in a team I hoped would win 84 games, winning 97 and advancing two rounds in the tournament. It to me was a huge success and personally included some of the best baseball fan memories I'll ever have with my son.

    Keep the faith Floyd, I know you will, the pint glass is half full and 2015 was just the start for this new group of Cubs!

    I enjoy your posts, it reminds me of how Cubs fandom run through generations. Have a wonderful offseason!

  • In reply to wpbc:

    Thanks for the kind words! It was indeed a great season that went all too quickly, as most great things do. Like you, I had the most fun I can remember with my family watching the incredible, highly unlikely year unfold. 2015 will soon be shorthand for "one of the best seasons ever."

    I just read an interview with Tom Ricketts in the Wall Street Journal. It was clipped for me by my sister. Ricketts said something to the effect that the goal is to reach the playoffs every year. After that, it's something of a crap shoot as to who wins it all. But if the Cubs are there most every year, the chances of them winning the WS is real. This sounded darn wise to me. When I wrote the above blog I was bemoaning the fact that the Cubs looked so good in one series, and then so bad in the next. I should have waited to compare the NLCS to the WS. The Mets' collapse must have been very hard on their fans, having the lead in every game they lost, including 2-0 going into the ninth inning of what would be the final game.

    So it's on to the hot stove league! The construction fences are back up around the entrance. Ernie's statue is gone, as is the marquee. But I can only imagine that Theo and Jed are busier than ever.

    We're ready for Spring Training ...

Leave a comment