Romney Doesn't Quite Get the Message Of "America The Beautiful"


On the stump in Iowa, Mitt Romney has been quoting lines from my favorite patriotic song, "America the Beautiful".  I'm sure he has every right to use this noble hymn  for political expediency . But I think he ought to get the politics of it right. Katherine Lee Bates who wrote the poem ---which was set to Samuel Ward's music--- was anything but a Conservative.  She was  an English professor---a teacher.  Her counterparts in America  today are not cut much slack by  the Right.  She was a feminist.  Not a popular figure in contemporarary Republican circles.  She believed in God, but was dissatisfied with the  institutional churches of her time--- late 19th and early 20th centuries. She lived with another woman who was the love of her life.  Now that would ruffle a few feathers in a GOP powwow. She did not advocate war and was vehemently  against the imperialism of the Spanish-American War. Unlike the hawkish Neo-Cons.   She was a social reformer who yearned to help the impoverished languishing in urban slums.  Community organizing got booed at the last Republican Convention, remember?

She fought for the rights of labor, long before collecitve bargaining, the eight-hour day, and the end of child labor.  You won't find much about these  in the Republican 2012 platform. And some Republicans are even nostalgic about early employment.

But most of all, Mr. Romney ---who says he's been ruminating on Miss Bates's famous words---should weigh and consider these lines  from 'America the Beautiful'. "America! America!/ God shed his grace on thee/ Till selfish gain no longer stain/ The banner of the free."

'Selfish gain' is so Republican.



Leave a comment
  • My thanks to the article author, this is a great story and has been well worth the time reading it. So I would just like to say thanks and it will be a please to come back and read more of them in the future. Thanks again!
    Webmaster of Nikon M223

Leave a comment