I received this very fine question on the To the Rescue! Facebook page, and know that this is the sticking point for many on the issue of puppy mills. While many people understand that the purchase of puppies from pet stores enables the puppy mill industry to thrive (see this article for a non-graphic explanation of puppy mills), well-intended people may yet consider making such a purchase because, they figure, at least the puppy is saved from the pet store.
After all, doesn't a pet store puppy have just as dire a need for a home as an shelter or rescue pup?
This is exactly the kind of dilemma puppy mill breeders and pet store owners hope you experience, even if you are morally and ethically opposed to the industry.
Compassionate people want to save, and that can include saving puppies from being in pet store cages. But looked at from the industry side, you can call it saving all you want but a sale is a sale is a sale. Every sale perpetuates the current model. Period.
Pet store puppies are treated as any other retail merchandise. Dee explained,
"The pet stores put the puppy on sale and keep reducing the price until they sell. They may also send them to a different store where they might sell better."
The price dropping will continue until the puppy either gets sold or grows to a point that the store feels it must cut its losses. At that point, they may give puppies away to employees, friends or rescue groups.
What is a compassionate animal lover to do?
According to Best Friends Animal Society, you may just need to institute a 'Do Not Enter" rule for stores that sell retail pets. It will release you from the temptation to buy that any animal lover would experience but more importantly, nothing, but nothing, gets a retailer to examine its business model like an empty store.
Dee Santucci points out, it really does boil down to simple economics.
The bottom line is, we won't get rid of the puppy mills until people STOP buying the puppies. It's supply and demand.
Interested in getting involved as a volunteer with The Puppy Mill Project? Their next orientation session is February 20th. Visit their event page on Facebook for details.
Care about issues like this one? Then be sure to subscribe!
To get a brief notice in your inbox when new posts go up, simply type your email address in the box and click the "create subscription" button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time. And be sure to follow me on Facebook for lots of great additional info you won't get here.
Filed under: Puppy Mills