Revolution 1 Fire 0 - recap and ratings

This surely isn't the start anyone had in mind after a 4-1-2 preseason provided some hope that the apparent lack of scoring punch could be handled by committee. The lack of finishing and creativity in the attacking third was overshadowed by a putrid defensive effort in the opener but the club's biggest concern going into 2013 was on full display in a disheartening 1-0 loss to the New England Revolution in the home opener.

"I thought we started the game well and created some chances in the first half but playing against the wind was a little bit more difficult and then we just gave up a set piece where we get caught ball watching and we give up a goal," said Frank Klopas in his post game press conference. "In the run of play we got in some good spots but we just didn't finish. We have to be better because obviously when you put your chances away it takes away a lot of pressure," continued Klopas.

The biggest offender in terms of botched chances was forward Sherjill MacDonald who is not only struggling with form but fitness has also been an issue throughout preseason. MacDonald was taken off at halftime after one particularly glaring chance was missed in the 27th minute. "We took out MacDonald because we needed him to hold the ball better and at times when we tried to find him he was late to his movement. He had a couple of chances he didn't put away and going against the wind I know that Maicon is bigger, stronger and we could use him to hold the ball a little bit better," said Klopas of his decision to remove the club's sole remaining designated player at half time.

MacDonald believes things will improve but wasn't giving any reason for his benching in the opener and his troubles in this match. "I don't know, you have to ask the coach but of course I was disappointed. As a player you have to listen to the coach," said MacDonald when asked about his issues in the first two games of 2013.  "I think we didn't have a fantastic first half but it was okay. The second half with the wind against us was a little bit more difficult," said MacDonald.

The Dutch forward still believes he's can recapture the rhythm he had with Chris Rolfe in 2012 which led to some success offensively but has failed to show so far this year. "I still think I have a good connection with Rolfe but in some games it works better than other games. I'm sure once the season gets going we're going to be okay," he said. Although he wasn't happy with the way his chances were taken in this one MacDonald maintains there are better days ahead. "This is my job. As a striker I know these things happen in soccer but I'm just there to support the team at all times. We'll be okay. Today was not a good game but maybe next game we'll score and everybody will talk different."

Rolfe also cited issues with the wind in the second half which curtailed what they were able to do offensively. "Going against the wind a little bit in the second half was a little difficult. I don't want to make an excuse but I think we were a little tired," he said. "The LA game was kind of an eye opener for us and I think in this game we were much better. We were unfortunate to not at least tie this game. We had three pretty clear cut chances that we weren't sharp on. Our defense played very well, that goal that they scored was just kind of a fluke," said Rolfe in comparing the first two matches of the year. "I don't know if it was Austin or his mark (that) could have came and cleared it. Normally they would've. Just a bit of lack of sharpness on our part," he said.

The midfield play has also not been particularly sharp but that was probably expected with three new starters occupying the four available positions in the middle. Joel Lindpere is being counted on the start the attack but things have been slow to develop in the early going. Lindpere knows that it's important to win at each opportunity but also noted that there is time to right the ship. "Bad things happen but the season is early. The teams I've played on before in this league have seen how this league is built. Everything starts at the end of the year. I know we've had a bad start but if we keep working hard those wins are not far. Maybe it's new guys working together but the ball just didn't go in," said Lindpere of the club's difficult start.  "We had some moments but we knew the only way they could score against us was on set pieces and they did it," he continued.

The season is early and there is surely time to develop the chemistry necessary to earn better results than the outcome of this match but whether it's early in the season or late, it's never a good thing to not only drop points but lose altogether at home while playing a conference opponent that should be behind you in the standings. Arne Friedrich's return may be weeks away and Klopas seems to have found a better combination with Anibaba in his place but the issue with goal scoring will remain. The midfield will need some time to gel and should improve. "Two weeks we lost the game," said Klopas when asked about the revamped midfield. "The effort was there from the group and I think we just have to keep working. Our problem now is a little bit in the back where we made some mistakes and we're paying for them," he said.

The Fire are staring right into the face of a possible 0-3 start to begin the season with a difficult trip to Kansas City on the horizon next Saturday. There's still plenty of time to correct some of the big concerns and this is a better team than they have shown over the first two games but at some point someone is going to have to score goals. That someone isn't wearing a red shirt yet.

Player Ratings

GK Sean Johnson (5) - New England didn't really have many opportunities to score but they did manage to convert on their only clear chance. Johnson registered two saves including an early stop of a 5th minute Kalifa Cisse header and that was about it.

D Gonzalo Segares (5) - Much better game for the veteran than last week with several stops against Toja particularly in the first half. New England recessed into defend and counter mode after the score in the 62nd minute so the second half didn't require as much activity.

D Jalil Anibaba (5) - Moved into a centerback spot to start the match and the switch provided an improvement over last week's effort in Los Angeles from a team standpoint. Moved back to the right side midway through the second when the Fire needed to press for a tying goal. "I knew with Bengston, who was more athletic I wanted to get Jalil in the back and during the game I switched them up again because I knew Steven was getting tired and we had to push the game. Jalil still had his legs and could push from the right side," explained Frank Klopas after the match.

D Austin Berry (5) - Good for the entire match with the exception of getting caught flat footed on the the cross that resulted in Bengston's goal in the 62nd. "It was just a broken down play. We cleared the first ball and didn't stick t0 marks on the second ball in. It's a shame because we defended well for the majority of the game," said Berry. "We're getting more comfortable (without Friedrich). Sliding in Jalil into the centerback spot there's a little more familiarity between me and him. It's getting better but we would like to have Arne back," he said.

D Steven Kinney (5) - A pretty good match for Kinney on the right side in the first half. Several crosses cleared and a great run out of the back in the 43rd minute were the highlights. Moved to centerback in the second half and was clearly gassed at the end of the game.

M Jeff Larentowicz (5) - The Fire won the possession battle 54-46 and New England rarely threatened as the Fire midfield was better (again during the first half in particular).

M Dilly Duka (5) - An improved outing from the previous week with periods of good activity cutting into a the middle of the field. His blast from almost 30 yards in the 31st minute was well struck and hit the crossbar after Matt Reis appeared to get a fingertip on the shot. The second half wasn't as eventful - he was subbed out in the 58th.

M Joel Lindpere (5) - Perhaps it's a function of the club's new midfield combination but Lindpere needs to be more involved going forward as a link to the strikers if the Fire are to improve offensively. There were moments (again in the first half) that included decent combination play but he disappeared for the most part in the second. "In the first half we played good and we had more opportunities to score. We've got believe that we're a better team," said Lindpere after the match.

M Patrick Nyarko (5) - He's not been as involved in the offense as he should have been in the first two games of the season. In last season's formation with two holding midfielders he had more freedom to get forward but with a flat 4-4-2 and one holding mid he's tended to hold back a bit more. The Fire need to find a way to get him the ball in dangerous positions. He continues to really only be stopped through grabs, lunges, and physical play. Had an excellent sequence in the 27th minute after stealing the ball and providing a cross to MacDonald all alone inside the six.

F Chris Rolfe (5) - Yet another player on the home team who started out very well in the first half only to level off in the second. His only shot came in the 26th when his left footed attempt sailed high after receiving a pass from Lindpere. Subbed out in the 66th minute. Klopas explained the substitution as an injury concern. "He had a muscle issue and he was grabbing his knee so we had to take him out. We were making a different change but then we had to take him out because he couldn't continue," said Klopas. Rolfe said the issue was a result of cramping and not an injury problem.

F Sherjill MacDonald (4) - His form and fitness are a big concern early in the season and as a designated player the pressure will be on for him to deliver....and soon. His muff of the scoring chance in the 27th minute was of the shockingly bad variety and another good look was sent woefully high in the 3rd after Rolfe and Kinney worked a combination to get him a chance. "I had one big chance. I think I had more time than I thought I had so I had to shoot real fast. These are the decisions you make some times and after the game you can see if it was a good decision or a bad decision," said MacDonald who was subbed out at halftime.

M Yazid Atouba (5) - Came into the match in the 58th minute as a replacement for Duka. The Revs scored 4 minutes later and retreated into a defensive formation. The Fire never really got anything going in the second half although Atouba was active.

M Alex (5) - Subbed in for Rolfe in the 66th but there wasn't much to speak of from the Fire offensively at any point after the 60th minute. I suspect the substitution Klopas originally had in mind in the 66th was a move to get Alex into a playmaking role in favor of Lindpere before Rolfe's "injury" concern.

F Maicon Santos (5) - An improvement over MacDonald with a good ball forward to Lindpere to start an attack in the 49th minute. A long distance prayer from 30 yards and a low shot right at Reis in stoppage time was all the Fire could muster in an effort to tie the game.

Filed under: 2013 Regular Season

Tags: Chicago Fire


Leave a comment
  • This team only has about 5 or 6 players that are worthy. Nyarko, Rolfe, Berry, Johnson, Freidrich and possibly Anibaba. Everyone else is just a mediocre player that wouldn't be really missed if they weren't there.

    On to the formation, we were beat in every position tonight. Lindpere is not a box to box or an attacking mid. He has no role, meaning he is useless out there. Jeff L is a taller Logan Pause. It's fine if we want to have a player like that but we need 3 in the middle then. A 433 makes more sense. We're asking too much of our outside mids with this formation. Having to defend because the wings are wide open was killing nyarko tonight.

    Coaching, wow... Down a goal and he takes off Rolfe? I guess it's better to lose 1-0 than 2-0. Leaving lindpere on the whole match is a mistake. Taking off Rolfe is a mistake. Starting McDonald is a mistake. The gameplay of bombing the ball forward no matter what is a mistake. Klopas was awful tonight. But I guess with the short week the players were tired..

  • In reply to Rubberbandman189:

    Some of those concerns, like the Rolfe substitution are addressed in the recap.

  • Well. You got NE's goal total right in your prediction.
    I fear that after next weekend, our win total and goal total will be the same. And I'm not predicting a 1-0 Chicago win.

  • In reply to Doug: prediction was a little off...but hey, there's a long way to go. ;)

  • A couple things struck me:

    1. Over the course of a season MacDonald won't miss those setters.
    2. Alstott did a good defensive job on Duka. He was faster, quicker and stronger and yet Duka got off one nice shot.
    3. MacDonald had trouble posting up the defender and got pushed around. I couldn't tell whether the trouble was the poor passing, poor movement on MacDonald's part, good defensive play, or uncalled fouls. Probably a bit of all four, although at the end of the day the defender got what he wanted and Sherjill got beat up.
    4. We didn't have an edge on team speed. Say what you will of Oduro - poor touches, shooting right at the goalie, bad passing - his speed put pressure on defenses that we curently don't have. Nyarko has the requisite speed but it isn't utilized very well.
    5. I don't recall seeing so many Fire passes go straight out of bounds.
    6. In the second half, New England did a great job of jumping in front of our passess. Was it the wind, the poor passing, our predicability, or the absence of fear of an over the top pass? I don't know, but half way through the second half it was pretty clear we had simply changed players and not tatics and a goal was unlikely.
    7. New England's offense was as poor as ours. They had three good opportunities. On one Sean Johnson came out when he shouldn't have and on the goal it looked like he should have gone out when he didn't. We had three opportunities: MacDonald's setters and Duka hitting the cross bar. We could have easily won this game, which makes it all the more frustrating.
    8. Did we get a corner?
    9. There were a number of "crosses" that amounted to a punt and all Reis had to do was play centerfield.
    10. When Nyarko has the ball on the side, everyone should realize he is going to go towards the end line and he will in all liklihood get in a low cross. It would behoove others to run towards the goal.
    11. I only saw a little bit of Fire players standing waiting for a teammate to get the ball. In LA, it was an epidemic.
    12. I seem to think that Rolfe and Nyarko were on the same side. If that's correct, is that a good idea? It seems to me that putting two of your faster players on the same side mitigates an advantage.
    13. I'm not sure about 50/50 balls but I felt the Fire did pretty well, at least better than last year. I could be wrong - there is probably some sort of stat on this - but my impression was that we battled well in this area.

    Frustrating to watch but I suspect more frustrating to play. I don't think they are as bad as some think but they will struggle to make playoffs. Nevertheless, it still something great to do on a Saturday night and is much more enjoyable than watching a pitcher pick at corners of the strike zone.

  • In reply to billj:

    Some good points in there billj. The Fire did not have one corner kick all night. The stat for "duels won" did indeed go in favor of the Fire 54-46 percent.

    Number 10 is a favorite of mine and yes I'll take it over 8 guys standing around while one guy throws a ball at another one any time.

  • In reply to billj:

    billj, I didn't know that Mike Alstott came of retirement and decide to suit up for the Revolution :)

  • I was at the game and some thoughts. MacDonald was frustrating to watch. Goalscorers put those chances away. I was disappointed in Kinney. He was okay, but he looked over-matched in several situations. New England was much more aggressive throughout the game. The Fire seemed wait for the pass while NE attacked the ball. What is with the team's lack of fitness at the end of games? Kinney could hardly run at the end. I did some some things in midfield that looked good with Lindpere and Larentowicz. Cold night, but great to see the season get underway. Unfortunately, a frustrating game.

  • Last night, I brought a friend attending his first MLS game. After watching MacDonald for about 20 minutes, he commented, "Number 7 looks a little overweight to me."

    The fitness issues MacDonald had last season were supposed to be due to his mid-season arrival. What's his excuse this year? What was he doing during 6 weeks of pre-season training? How can Frank start a striker who isn't fit?

    And now Rolfe is saying the team was tired? How can these players be tired in the second week of the season? I want to remain an optimist, but the Fire looked weak against a poor opponent. Frank needs to figure this out, and fast.

  • In reply to StaryByk3:

    MacDonald may play himself right out of a spot come July if he doesnt gather himself quickly. The Fire need to improve drastically at that position and I believe the technical staff realizes that.

    This team is better than they've shown over the first two games though.

  • In reply to StaryByk3:

    I'm with you, I hate the excuses that are being dropped by this team..the team needs a bit more mental toughness and accountability.

  • First chance to watch an entire game this year -- nuts!!!
    Except for McDonald, I generally enjoyed the first half. Some excellent, skillful passing sequences. I thought Duka showed some good moves but he needs some coaching!! It's easy to see why he excelled against college defenders but he needs to understand that he's not a Messi -- 2 or 3 touches, then pass or shoot. Second half was "disappointing" to say the least. While subbing Rolf appears explainable, why Duka too?
    I have usually been patient with Frank but this was definitely a bad outing. I have never been a fan of MacDonald even when he and Rolfe were on a roll last year. He reminds me of the old english target men, primarily just big and strong! Santos has the same basics as MacDonald but can actually dribble a bit. I will be shocked if MacDonald is here for 4th of July celebrations.
    I am a fan of Jalil and think he has an excellent future. Right now he is a liability when it comes to playing out of the back -- much too tentative /slow. He will get better!
    One final thought -- when will the Fire get a legitimate DP?
    the money they've wasted on "projects", "rehabs", etc would have been enough to garner something. Is it just the money or is it that we can't evaluate talent?
    Oh what the H---! Go Fire

  • I'll be recapping the home opener tomorrow morning on ESPN 1220am at 7:30.

    Also look for a new Fire Confidential Podcast episode tomorrow.

  • Check out the latest episode of the Fire Confidential Podcast recapping Saturday's game.....

  • As has been noted, this is a good team, albeit a team that needs to find some cohesiveness quickly.

    Mackie's finishing is going to earn him a ticket out of town, but his fitness is going to land him on the bench far before July ever gets here. Frank being so vocal in the postgame press conference about his displeasure in Mackie's play is telling. I definitely sense a Toronto FC/de Guzman type situation unfolding here.

    Many of the supporters in Section 8 voiced displeasure this weekend over the team not coming over to the Harlem End after the match. People are pointing at Larentowicz for not acknowledging the fans because he's wearing the armband, but there are plenty of guys who've been w/ the club and know the culture like Segares, Nyarko, Rolfe, and even Paladini who need to make those guys aware that reciprocation is important to the fanbase.

  • Kellen Gulley begins training with the Atlanta Silverbacks as the Fire continue to pursue a loan deal for the Homegrown forward.....

  • Fire Reserve schedule listing shows 13 games (the 4/7 match against New York is no longer listed).....

  • Arne Friedrich seeing a therapist in Germany to treat his injury. Should be back in Chicago in 2 weeks....

    There's no reason to panic just yet. Friedrich is seeing a therapist that has helped him recover from injuries in the past. Speaking with Arne last week he said that after an initial scare, test results showed that the injury wasn't season or career threatening and was actually not as bad as the injury he suffered last season.

  • I'm sure I'm stealing someone's tweet, but how long before the Fire trade a draft pick or allocation order for Obafemi Martins?

    Man this is a nightmare start for the Men in Red. I'm going to loathe my season seats next to the away fans this year...

  • In reply to c0quito18:

    That joke is quickly making the rounds.....have patience - it's a long season and they're better than they've shown so far.

Leave a comment