Dirty Tactics in Divorce: Are They Necessary?

At the recent Divorce University I listened to many wonderful speakers talking about the legal, financial and emotional aspects of divorce. Dirty tactics was not on the list of topics

One of the speakers said that a divorce is 80% emotional, 10% financial and 10% legal.  Hold that thought for a moment.

In the course of the day I spoke to a woman who was recently divorced.  I always ask (if they are willing to discuss their affairs with me) who her attorney was and who the husband’s attorney was. I also ask if they liked their attorney and why or why not.  And I also like to know what the husband’s attorney was like.

So in talking to this woman, she told me something that rang true with my experience:  “My X’s attorney was very nasty to me, it really bothered me that she could be so mean to me.”

Oh my gosh!

That brought back a vivid memory of my X’s attorney saying to me in court this last proceeding, “It is your fault that we are here.”

What?

Either she was acting or she had drunk the Kool-Aid that my X fed her. Apparently since I had asked for permanent support and got it, and he was compelled to file this current motion to reduce or terminate  that amount, it “was all my fault.” They also unnecessarily conducted this proceeding like Sherman’s army marching through Georgia after the Civil War.

This lawyer conveniently ignored  the fact that my lawyers and I had tried to negotiate a settlement to avoid the first trial (and  many dollars in legal fees) as well as this second proceeding.  And yet, it was my fault!

Got that?

OK....now back to the woman I spoke with.  She was really upset that her X’s attorney was mean to her.  Of course, this is a strategy usually (but not always) employed by the husband. It is especially used on any woman whose self esteem was trampled during the marriage.  When a woman is already vulnerable, this can be extremely effective.

Women hear this:  one of the oldest strategies in a high conflict divorce is to wear down, wear out, demean and harass the wife.  The goal is to get her to throw up her hands and give in, to accept a settlement that is less than that to which she would be entitled.

Do attorneys really need to be so mean in order to represent their clients well?

In my own experience, all but one [and there have been lots as my X has gone through many Chicago lawyers during these proceedings] of my X’s attorneys were all rather malevolent to me.  Only James H. Feldman, from Jenner & Block was a gentleman and was never caustic, provocative or vicious to me in the appellate mediation proceedings we went through prior to the full on appellate procedure (which resulted in an Illinois Appellate Court decision in my favor).

So my wish is that all attorneys know that they can represent their clients well without being brutal to the opponent. Why add to someone’s misery in the name of being an advocate?

If you have the law and the facts on your side, you do not need to resort to such sleazy tactics.

Let’s change those percentages from above to 40% financial, 40% legal and 20% emotional.

 

You can subscribe to all my posts by entering your email address in the box to the right.

Follow me on Twitter: @Twitter

 

Leave a comment

  • ChicagoNow is full of win

    Welcome to ChicagoNow.

    Meet our bloggers,
    post comments, or
    pitch your blog idea.

  • Advertisement:
  • Meet The Blogger

    Donna

    I filed for a divorce in 2003. I had no idea that ELEVEN years on, that I would still be in divorce-related litigation. There have been two trials, an appellate court decision affirming the original trial decision, numerous other hearings, depositions and more. A second appellate court decision is pending. I write mostly from the woman's point of view. Or rather, the spouse who stayed home and raised the children, the one who gave up a career. When first married, I worked as a law librarian and do have a law degree but never practiced. Having that law degree has given me insights into the often mysterious ways of the legal system, especially in Cook County. Recently I have reactivated my law license, became an Enrolled Agent [a license given by the IRS after taking a series of tests] and prepare tax returns. Please share your experiences or ask me questions. Email me at divorcechicagostyle@gmail.com Follow me on Twitter for articles and and news about Illinois Appellate Court divorce related decisions.

  • Latest on ChicagoNow

  • Advertisement:
  • Fresh Chicago News