It's hard not to think of incoming president George Bush's 2000 pick of Houston superintendent Rod Paige right now.
Like Paige, Duncan comes from a big city with a success story that the national press failed to figure out was mostly a mirage. Like Paige, Duncan will soon find out that he will be a figurehead who answers to instructions from campaign veterans who are already installed inside the DPC. Like Paige, Duncan may find himself frustrated and outflanked by powerful stakeholders (Congress, Republicans, national teachers unions) he hasn't really had to deal with before in Chicago.
Looking back at Duncan's record, the specific moments that concern me the most include (a) last year year when Duncan went along with a cynical and failed Mayoral effort to link citywide gang violence with the school system -- even though little of the violence was taking place in school, (b) Duncan's stubborn resistance against NCLB transfers, tutoring, and accountability requirements that he will now be enforcing, (c) Duncan's insistence on closing buildings down for a year to turn them around, and (d) his failure to revamp the teachers contract, which gives annual raises but still calls for an extremely short day and short year.
The bottom line is that, given sweeping powers over schools and a powerful political patron, Duncan's efforts failed to convince more white and middle class parents to send their kids to public schools, and failed to convince downstate legislators to revamp the state funding system despite Democratic control of the legislature and the Governor's mansion.
Duncan wasn't just a caretaker of the school system, but he certainly wasn't really all that bold or inspiring. He was a safe choice. A mayoral appointee in a one-party town, there's not that much in Duncan's record to suggest he has been able to wrestle diverse factions into concerted action.
That being said, Duncan is a hard-working, good guy, nonconfrontational and non-ideological by and large. I'm glad the selection process is over -- it had gone on too long. Duncan doesn't make people crazy. He's avoided stepping into unnecessary side debates, by and large. And he's an underdog -- always being underestimated and usually exceeding expectations. So maybe he'll surprise us all.
In the meantime, I hope that the national press will look a little bit deeper into the Chicago miracle, and take a moment to ponder why the folks they're quoting are saying such nice things about him. No one's looked at Chicago's lame NAEP scores or anemic charter program. Most of the folks who are gushing about him don't really know him (or Chicago) that well, or hope to work for him in the near future, or are approving of him because they think that they can beat him in DC.
Next up: wondering whether Duncan, who currently sends his daughter to public school, will transfer her to a DCPS school or to a private one.
Filed under: When Washington Attacks