Can the government make you buy broccoli?

The Obama administration's answer: "It depends."

This is the remarkable answer that an administration lawyer responded to an appellate judge's question. It came during a court hearing on the ObamaCare provision that requires all Americans to buy health insurance. Here is the exchange:

“Let’s go right to what is your most difficult problem,” Judge Laurence H. Silberman, who later voted to uphold the law, told a lawyer at an argument in September before the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. “What limiting principle do you articulate?” If Congress may require people to purchase health insurance, he asked, what else can it force them to buy? Where do you draw the line?

Would it be unconstitutional, he asked, to require people to buy broccoli?

“No,” said the lawyer, Beth S. Brinkmann. “It depends.”

She didn't elaborate on what it "depends" on, and was hit with some other examples:

Could people making more than $500,000 be required to buy cars from General Motors to keep it in business?

“I would have to know much more about the empirical findings,” she replied.

Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh, who ended up in dissent, then jumped in. “How about mandatory retirement accounts replacing Social Security?” he asked.

“It would depend,” Ms. Brinkmann replied.

This exchange in found in an excellent New York Times article by Adam Liptak, in which he explains the central issues that the U.S. Supreme Court will take up when it considers that constitutionality of ObamaCare.

Leave a comment

  • ChicagoNow is full of win

    Welcome to ChicagoNow.

    Meet our bloggers,
    post comments, or
    pitch your blog idea.

  • Advertisement:
  • Subscribe to The Barbershop

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Dennis Byrne’s Facebook Fan Page

  • Like me on Facebook

  • google-site-verification: googlefdc32e3d5108044f.html
  • Meet The Blogger

    Dennis Byrne

    Chicago Tribune contributing op-ed columnist and author of forthcoming historical novel, "Madness: The War of 1812." Reporter, editor and columnist for Chicago Sun-Times and Chicago Daily News. Freelance writer and editor.

  • Our National Debt

  • Twitter

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • In reply to Rick Bohning:
      I get the analogy, but where it fails is with the assumption that all contraception is equally efficacious in all ...
      Read the story | Reply to this comment
    • In reply to Aquinas wired:
      Logical fallacy: Ad Hominem Tu Quoque. Look it up. In short, hypocrisy does not make or break ...
      Read the story | Reply to this comment
    • In reply to hatch3:
      Another logical fallacy: appeal to authority. Just because the experts claim it to be true, does not make ...
      Read the story | Reply to this comment
    • In reply to Dennis Byrne:
      I think I'll go with the experts on this one. https://www.acog.org/About_ACOG/ACOG_Departments/Health_Care_for_Underserved_Women/Frequently_Asked_Questions_about_Hormonal_Approaches_to_Emergency_Contraception "4. Does this mean that emergency contraception can cause an ...
      Read the story | Reply to this comment
    • I don't see how covering these contraceptives for their employees is violating the religious freedom of the owners of ...
      Read the story | Reply to this comment
  • Monthly Archives

  • /Users/dennisby/Desktop/trailer.mp4
  • Advertisement:
  • Fresh Chicago News