The Cardinals Blueprint Shows Why The Pressure Is On For The Cubs

The Cardinals Blueprint Shows Why The Pressure Is On For The Cubs

We're halfway through Year 3 of the massive, and much maligned, Cubs rebuilding project of terror. Rather than write about moves that have turned into absolute gold (Feldman for Arrieta, Marshall for Wood) or write about moves that are still perplexing (Edwin Jackson, Ian Stewart), I thought I'd cover something different: the St. Louis Cardinals.

Do you get the same cold chill when reading those words that I do? That same jealous anger? You want to hate them so much because their fans just suck in every single way, but you're also smart enough to recognize that everything about the way they carry out baseball operations is what you want for your beloved Cubs.

You're jealous that it seems like they've sprinkled pixie dust on broken arms like Chris Carpenter and turned them into borderline Hall-of-Famers. You're jealous because they find guys like Albert Pujols beyond the top 10 rounds of the draft. And you're jealous because they can win just 83 games in a season and still win the World Series.

Some have compared the way the Cardinals built towards what they are now to what the Cubs are currently doing, but this is only a somewhat fair comparison. The CBA was different 20 years ago, and the Cardinals were able to build a talented and deep minor league system without having to completely tank any seasons (although they did lose). Let's take a look at the history.

The Cards won 95 games and lost in the World Series in 1987. But starting in 1988, the franchise went the next 12 seasons without winning 90 games. They made the playoffs only one time, sneaking in with 88 wins in 1996. From 1988 through 1994, the Cardinals' record was 537-542.

In October of 1994, the Cards hired Walt Jocketty as their new GM, and guess what? They really didn't get a ton better. From 1995-1999, their record was 383-414. But Jocketty knew what he was doing.

When he started, the Cards had two top-100 prospects (Brian Barber and Dmitri Young). By 1999, they would have five guys in the top 100 and two more on the list that they had traded just months before. Jocketty made a habit of doing what is now commonly referred to as going “overslot” in the draft, as well as finding talent in late rounds that other people missed.

Among those diamonds in the rough:

1995: Junior Spivey (28th round)

1995: Kerry Robinson (34th round)

1995: Cliff Politte (54th round)

1997: Rick Ankiel (2nd round)

1999: Coco Crisp (9th round)

1999: Albert Pujols (13th round)

2000: Yadier Molina (4th round)

2001: Dan Haren (2nd round)

2003: Ian Kennedy* (14th round)

2003: Anthony Reyes (15th round)

2005: Jaime Garcia (22nd round)

Along with a solid run of 1st round picks, Jocketty had the Cardinals farm system stocked in the late 90's. He then used that system to make a few deals that set the team up for the beginning of that run of success:

7/31/1997: Eric Ludwick, Blake Stein, and T.J. Mathews for Mark McGwire

7/31/1998: Royce Clayton and Todd Stottlemyre for Fernando Tatis and Darren Oliver

12/14/1998: Armando Almanza, Braden Looper, and Pablo Ozuna for Edgar Renteria

11/16/1999: Manny Aybar, Jose Jimenez, and 2 others for Darryl Kile and Dave Veres

12/20/1999: Juan Acevado for Fernando Vina

3/23/2000: Kent Bottenfield and Adam Kennedy for Jim Edmonds

If you weren't raised on 1990's baseball, there's a good chance most of those names mean nothing to you. But take my word for it: the Cardinals won every single one of those trades, most by a large margin. Their deep minor league system allowed them to build a core for their early 2000's success.

Then there are the notable free agent signings:

1995: Ron Gant

1999: Mike Matheny

2000: Andy Benes

2001: Jason Isringhausen

2002: Tino Martinez

2002: Chris Carpenter (1 year/$500K)

It's not like I'm leaving out his list of big, bad free agent deals, either. The Cards did a great job of assembling a core and moving forward with it while continuing to replenish the farm system, all without having to throw huge contracts at free agents. But the point of all of this is that it didn't happen overnight. Recall that Walt Jocketty arrived in 1994, but that the sustained success didn't begin until 2000.

You probably can see where I am going with this: patience, my friends. The Cubs are now halfway through the 3rd season of their total tear-down and rebuild. The good news is that Theo and the gang have built a deep, top-heavy farm system in a short amount of time. This fact is unavoidable in any conversation about the Cubs these days.

To me, the clear comparison is that Epstein and Hoyer are quickly approaching that position the Cardinals were in when they started putting together all of those deals. The top minor league players are about to explode into the majors in 2015. In 1998, the Cards won 83 games on the back of McGwire's historic season. But they had a bad pitching staff and their starting lineup's average age was 32.3.

With prospects like Morris, Ankiel, Tatis, Placido Polanco, and JD Drew arriving quickly, Jocketty recognized the proper time to build his core. Two seasons later, they would win the division. The Cubs must do the same at the trade deadline and going into the off-season. That means they need to seriously scrutinize any trade that doesn't bring back talent that can compete on the Major League roster next season.

With potentially an entire outfield to fill, plus a few rotation spots, and a ton of money to spend on the payroll in a relatively barren free agent market, the ball is in the Cubs' court. There are probably at least a few players on the trade market that they could target in the off-season. There are a handful of free agents that could fit in and help support the young core.

As we physically see the rebuild begin to turn the corner on the field, the pressure is finally on in the front office. It's time to start assembling a winner.

*Kennedy was drafted by the Cardinals after his senior year of HS but opted to attend USC instead; he was later drafted by the Yankees in 2006.


Thanks for reading; if you enjoyed it, please share with others.  And if you'd like to be updated on my future posts, and those from the rest of the Cubs Insider team, you can subscribe below.

Type your email address in the box and click the "create subscription" button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.

And be sure to like Cubs Insider on Facebook. You can also submit to reddit

Filed under: Uncategorized


Leave a comment
  • fb_avatar

    Nice piece... One correction, though. Kennedy was drafted by the Yankees 21st overall in 2006.

  • fb_avatar
    In reply to Phil James:

    Actually, following Kennedy's senior year of HS, the St. Louis Cardinals drafted him in the 14th round of the 2003 Amateur Draft, but he instead opted to attend the University of Southern California.

    So while he was never a Card, I think Ryan is pointing more to WJ's skill in finding value late in draft. Added note to provide some clarity though.

  • In reply to Phil James:

    Yeah, what Evan said. Sorry if it was unclear, I was more pointing at talent that WJ reconized and drafted. Glad you enjoyed it!

  • Good stuff Ryan. I'm always happy to emulate the Cardinals.

  • Major Trades under Theo Era.....

    Colvin, LeMahieu for I. Stewart.....................Rockies Winner
    Marshall for T Wood.....................................Cubs Winner
    Zambrano for Volstad..................................No Winner
    Cashner for Rizzo........................................Cubs Winner
    Maholm for Vizcaino...................................TBD
    Soto for Loux..............................................TBD
    Dempster for Hendricks & C. Villanueva........Cubs Winner
    Feldman for Arietta & Strop........................Cubs Winner
    Soriano for C. Black...................................TBD

  • In reply to CubsTalk:

    Getting rid of Zambrano is a win in my book

  • In reply to jorel1114:

    Why not just waive the guy at that point?.......I just was hoping that Volstad could have been flipped later for a prospect.

  • fb_avatar
    In reply to CubsTalk:

    I don't think there is any reason to give any of those moves a TBD. In the Maholm and Soriano trades, even if Vizcaino goes to the bullpen and Black remains nothing more than organizational depth, the Cubs come out ahead because they turned short-term obligations into long term potential. If they both happen fortify the major league bullpen than the Cubs are turning a perpetual weakness into a team strength. I give the Cubs wins in both of those moves.

    The Soto for Loux trade is a definite wash.

    And the Zambrano trade is a win just because nobody would take Big Z as he was a verifiable head case and cancer. It was a win just finding any team to take him. He was genuinely washed up at that point anyway.

    The Ian Stewart trade was a reach, and I'm sure the FO knows it, they were just hoping to possibly turn around a guy who had a small sample size record of success followed by absolute wretchedness. I'm sure they'd like that one back, but you cannot win every trade.

  • fb_avatar
    In reply to Michael Canter:

    Totally agree on Z trade. Dude was out of baseball within a year.

  • In reply to Evan Altman:

    Z was totally out of his head.........I just think Z thought he was bigger star then most people thought he was.

  • In reply to Michael Canter:

    Hopefully, Vizcaino will help us.....but we could have held on Maholm longer.

  • In reply to CubsTalk:

    What would not trading Maholm for Vizcaino have accomplished, other than possibly winning enough games to not land Kris Bryant? Also, keeping Maholm past 2012 likely means Feldman isn't signed. So, no Arrieta.

Leave a comment