March (Meh)dness: All-Time Greatest Cubs Bracket (Round 1, Pt 1)

March (Meh)dness: All-Time Greatest Cubs Bracket (Round 1, Pt 1)

After an exciting play-in round that saw a fictional player, a Bull, and Domingo Ramos move on to the next round.  Sure, it's a little funky.  But if loving the Cubs, and having a little fun with it, is Wrona, I don't wanna be Ryne.  Wait.  Scratch that, reverse it.

Most of the casualties from yesterday were names that many wouldn't have included in the list anyway, but now we're getting into the big boys.  These are the prisoners we've locked away in our friendly mental confines without chance for parole.  But don't worry; even if this bracket breaks them out, the recidivism rate for Cubs fans is incredibly high.

This edition will cover both the PK Wrigley and the Tribune Co. Regions, with the next two regions finishing up play tomorrow.  So turn off those TVs, because you're going to want to devote your undivided attention to the gloriousness that awaits you in the words below.  Okay, that was really overwrought; you can keep the basketball games on.  After all, your boss will better understand that than the idea that you're spending time at work looking at a fake bracket of the all-time greatest Cubs players.

PK Wrigley Region

1 Ryne Sandberg vs. 16 Steve Buechele

This really doesn't need any explanation, does it?

8 Jimmy Ryan vs. 9 Bruce Sutter

As much about setting up a 2nd-round matchup as it was their respective Cubs careers, Sutter's super splitter made him one of the game's most-feared closers.  While he's probably best-known to most modern Cubs fans as the man who helped to launch Ryne Sandberg's legend, he's also half of the trade that brought Leon "Bull" Durham to Chicago.  Durham supplanted Tom Loxas's beloved Bill Buckner at first base, eventually helping to lead the team to the 1984 NL East title and a pennant shot. Of course, Bull and Buck became best known for booting balls burying dreams.

5 Charlie Root vs. 12 Henry Rowengartner

Funky butt lovin'!  How can a fictional 12-year-old fireballer uproot the great Charlie?  Even Reds great Joe Nuxhall was 16 when he made his MLB debut.  Ah, but these are the Cubs, and it's just about as likely that a fake player could make his way through the bracket as the team could go more than a century without a title.

4 Phil Cavaretta vs. 13 Aramis Ramirez

Cinderfella is alive and kicking in this region, as Ram-Ram pulls the upset to secure a matchup with Runamucker in Round 2.

6 Lee Smith vs. 11 Claude Passeau

Who could forget Big Lee Smith strolling lazily from the bullpen?  He was Heath Bell's polar opposite and one of the game's best

3 Andre Dawson vs. 14 Randy Hundley

Sorry, Rebel, but you're no match for Hawk.

7 Stan Hack vs. 10 Don Kessinger

Not a very sexy matchup, this was a grinder.

2 Mordecai Brown vs. 15 Scott Sanderson

Perhaps a more fitting matchup would have pitted the 3-fingered Brown against the 6-fingered Antonio Alfonseca.  Either way, Mordecai's digital deficiency didn't slow him down in dispatching Sanderson.


Tribune Company Region

1 Ron Santo vs. 16 Rick Wrona

Wrona's run stops with Ron.

8 Frank Chance vs. 9 Larry Corcoran

In the same region as his famous double-play duo, Chance is the first to move on, easily defeating the 9 seed in Larry Corcoran.

5 Bill Buckner vs. 12 Bull Durham

Ah, sweet redemption.  Okay, winning a fake matchup with Durham isn't going to earn back either the World Series or his pride, but at least it's a start, right?

4 Hippo Vaughn vs. 13 Derrek Lee

Dude's name is Hippo, no way he loses.  D-Lee put in work, but simply couldn't overcome his opponent in this one.

6 Riggs Stephenson vs. 11 Bill Nicholson

I honestly have nothing to say about this matchup.  I could look up all the exploits of each player and provide a comprehensive breakdown, but that would really go against the spirit of this whole exercise.

3 Joe Tinker vs. 14 Clark Griffith

Joe Tinker, the seminal point man in the most famous double-play trio of all time, moves on over a man I know virtually nothing about.  Perhaps that's because he played in the 19th century.  But in this battle of old-school Cubs, being the titular figure in a famous poem and winning the last Cubs WS titles carries some weight.

7 Johnny Evers vs. 10 Shawon Dunston

Alas, it would be too easy to see all three legends pass through to round 2.  But before any panties get twisted, I just need to ask one question: did fans ever construct a John-O-Meter?  No?  Well, how great could he really have been.  Shawon Dunston had his right arm replaced with a Howitzer and was turning infield hits into doubles well before anyone had heard of Billy Hamilton.  The unique spelling of his and having a son in the Cubs organization were also points in Dunston's favor.

2 Hack Wilson vs. 15 Manny Trillo

Basically a fire hydrant with legs, Wilson could advance on the strength of his 1930 season alone.  That is, if you consider a .356 BA with 56 homers and 191 ribbies to be an exceptional campaign.  I mean, that's pretty good, I guess.  Plus, the dude was 5'6" and 190 lb and played CF; that's badass, no matter what era we're talking about.

And with that, we've made it halfway through Round 1.  Join me tomorrow for a look at the Spalding and Weeghman Regions, narrowing the field to 32.

Follow me on Twitter: @DEvanAltman

Thanks for reading; if you enjoyed it, please share with others.  And if you'd like to be updated on my future posts, and those from the rest of the Cubs Insider team, you can subscribe below.

Type your email address in the box and click the "create subscription" button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.


Filed under: Uncategorized


Leave a comment
  • Johnny Evers out! Nooooooooo! He was personally responsible for the last World Series the Cubs won!

  • fb_avatar
    In reply to Floyd Sullivan:

    Yeah, that was a tough one, but I loved Dunston. And what fun would this be without a little controversy.

  • As much as I loved me some Buckner, I really dug Bull Durham as well. Tough match up.

Leave a comment