Notre Dame Lands Top QB Prospect, 3 Other Key Transfers

Notre Dame Lands Top QB Prospect, 3 Other Key Transfers

The biggest news of the day, at least in the college football world, is Notre Dame landing #2 quarterback, #20 overall in the class of 2012 according to ESPNU recruit Gunner Kiel- who de-committed from both LSU and the Hoosiers to get here.

Today, recruits are more about getting playing time now, and less about redshirting and waiting in the wings. With Dayne Crist gone to Kansas, and the flux of the Tommy Rees vs. Andrew Hendrix situation, Kiel’s decision says a lot about the QB situation in South Bend. Coach Brian Kelly may love Tommy Rees, and there is future potential in both Andrew Hendrix and Everett Golson, but apparently Kiel feels he can get the QB1 gig in reasonably short time.

Let’s look at who else is going to the Golden Dome with Kiel today.


Additions to Notre Dame football team:

Name                                      Pos.     Ht.       Wt.      Hometown (High School)

Amir Carlisle^                         RB       5-10     180      Santa Clara, CA (Kings Academy)

Sheldon Day*                         DL       6-2       286      Indianapolis, IN (Warren Central)

Gunner Kiel*                          QB      6-4       220      Columbus, IN (Columbus East)

Tee Shepard*                          DB      6-1       186      Fresno, CA (Washington Union)


^ – Transfer from USC

* – Early-enrollee freshman

Carlisle will have to sit out 2012 but will have three seasons of eligibility remaining beginning in 2013.

Carlisle played in eight games for USC in 2011. He totaled 19 rushes for 118 yards (6.2 yards per carry) and posted seven receptions for 41 yards with one touchdown. His best game for the Trojans came at Colorado when Carlisle had 90 yards on 10 carries and caught two passes for 31 yards, including a 19-yard TD reception.

Shepard was rated the third-best cornerback in his class by and the number-36 player nationally by MaxPreps and Tom Lemming. Shepard was forced to sit out his senior season after transferring from Central East High School in Fresno. He made 10 interceptions in his high school career and played in the Semper Fidelis All-American Bowl in Phoenix.

Day was a second-team selection on the High School All-America team. The Indianapolis Star Super Team Player of the Year for 2011 was also runner-up for 2011Indiana Mr. Football award chosen by Indiana Football Coaches Association

Notre Dame will lose a good chunk of their offensive line, and team MVP wide receiver Michael Floyd on offense. Seven starters graduate on defense, so these replenishments will help them out greatly in rebuilding/reloading next year.

The de-committing not once, but twice is kind of a red flag. Especially for such a high-profile recruit like Kiel. Because you know he's had exalted status everywhere he's been in life, and might be getting a big head because of it. Most super-recruits do. Changing commitments happens all the time, but twice is rare. As is de-committing from two schools. It's kind of like the beginning of a college football version of the Alex Legion college basketball story. Legion de-confirmed his commitment to the Kentucky Wildcats and the Michigan Wolverines- twice. Then he transferred to the Illinois Fighting Illini where he accomplished very little.

The consensus top 50 recruit then went to Florida international, where he was kicked out of school. Legion had a reputation as a head case, and is the quintessential flame-out story. Kiel has a long way to go to live up to those comparisons, but he's not off to the best start.

Paul M. Banks is CEO of The Sports, an official Google News site generating millions of unique visitors. He’s also a regular contributor to Chicago Now, Walter, Yardbarker, and Fox Sports

A Fulbright scholar and MBA, Banks has appeared on live radio all over the world; and he's a member of the Football Writers Association of America, U.S. Basketball Writers Association, and Society of Professional Journalists. The President of the United States follows him on Twitter (@Paul_M_BanksTSB) You should too


Leave a comment