Kevin Coble isn't coming back, but he wasn't the answer anyways

INDIANAPOLIS - MARCH 12:  Kevin Coble #44 of the Northwestern Wildcats handles the ball against the Minnesota Golden Gophers during the first round of the Big Ten Men's Basketball Tournament at Conseco Fieldhouse on March 12, 2009 in Indianapolis, Indiana.  (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

By now you've heard that Kevin Coble will not play for the Northwestern Wildcats during the 2010-11 season, or ever again. The recovery from his broken foot is taking longer than expected, and instead of continuing through grueling rehab with the chance of injuring it again during the season which would come with possible life-altering implications, Coble has decided to hang up his basketball shoes. Of course, this story is getting a lot of national attention because of Northwestern's NCAA Tournament drought and the fact that "everyone" thought that Coble returning was the magic elixir that was going to solve all of the Wildcats' problems.
I'm hear to tell you that "they" were wrong. Coble's return wasn't going to fix the thing that Northwestern has to work on more than anything to make the NCAA Tournament - defense. The Wildcats had one of the most efficient offenses in the country last season. They scored 1.12 points per possession, which ranked 33rd in the country according to Ken Pomeroy's adjusted efficiency statistics. Being the 33rd best offense in the country is more than enough to make the NCAA Tournament. The problem was Northwestern's 168th ranked defense.
If Coble had been able to return at full strength this season he still wouldn't have provided the defensive presence that the Wildcats needed. A foot injury is exactly the type of problem that hinders your lateral movement, and it is the key to staying in front of people with the basketball. Even when the doctors say you're fully recovered these types of injuries aren't over. So even if Coble had completed his rehab he'd probably be wondering, "What happens if I try this?" on the basketball court. If you're taking time to wonder you're taking too long.
When Coble was healthy he led the Wildcats in scoring and rebounding, and while his rebounding would be nice, his scoring wouldn't be necessary. Coble had been essentially the same player his first three seasons with an offensive rating around 110 in approximately a quarter of the team's possessions while he was on the court. He also had a rebounding rate of 2.7 percent on the offensive boards and 15.5 percent on the defensive boards. 
You know whose numbers were better than that last season? John Shurna. Shurna replaced Coble in the lineup and became an even better offensive threat. He's still improving too. His national team experiences appear to have helped him elevate his game. It's also worth noting that Drew Crawford, as a freshman, put up an offensive rating of 107.5 and Michael Thompson put up a ridiculous 115.9 last season. With JerShon Cobb coming in and Alex Marcotullio improving, the Wildcats are surely going to be just as good, if not better, on offense next season.
But what about the rebounding? Would Coble have helped that much there? Maybe. Laugh if you want, but Kyle Rowley - who transfered to St. Mary's - led this team in defensive rebounding percentage last season. There are players on the court that have to want to get the ball. I firmly believe that rebounding is about athleticism and desire. If this is truly Northwestern's most athletic team ever then the boards should come. Rebounding also comes down to scheme. At some point Bill Carmody is going to have to realize that the 1-3-1, while great for an occasional change of pace, shouldn't be a team's main offering. If this is truly Northwestern's most athletic team ever, and if Jeff Ryan returns completely healthy, expect the Wildcats to play more man-to-man and other more traditional defenses during the season.
Finally, Coble wasn't coming back to be a leader. Sure he's made some clutch baskets in the past, no one will ever forget his show against Michigan State in 2009, but this is Thompson's team now. He's the leader of the team, and the most critical piece of the lineup. With Ryan returning the team won't lack for leadership, and they'll have two weeks of practice and playing time in Italy this summer to continue to bond together.
The team is going to be alright without Coble. The sky is not falling in Evanston - I know because I work there. The Wildcats can, and should, win this season. At worst they should be a middle of the pack Big Ten team. With the NCAA Tournament newly expanded to 68 teams there is room for another one of those. There are no excuses. Now is still the Wildcats' time.
And as for Coble. This is where his saga ends. He gave this team three years of his life and lost one to a difficult foot injury. He dealt with his mother's cancer, during which he also missed some time, and the rigorous academic expectations of Northwestern. He's served as an example to many that you can be successful on the court at Nortwestern. He'll be graduating in December and he should be thanked for his efforts. Coble decided his life long health was more important than hanging on for the chance at an NCAA Tournament berth, that's a decision I hope that all 22-year-olds would be mature enough to make.
Some Other Takes On Coble Leaving:
It should be noted that this post will be cross-posted over at Rush the Court.

Leave a comment