Hamilton, hurt or told to stay home?

When asked if Rip Hamilton would miss the rest of the season, Tom Thibodeau hedged in such a way to indicate that it was a significant possibility. Given that Hamilton was kind of a train wreck anyway and Marco Belinelli has been better, there's at least some part of me that has to wonder if Hamilton was requested to stay away or if he's really hurt.

Back injuries can be tricky, and the Bulls have certainly gone Bill Belichik style when it comes to obfuscating and hiding injurie, so we'll never know how bad Rip's back really is. However, it feels like the Bulls are better off with Hamilton gone and tweaking your back typically wouldn't be something you'd expect to be a season ender (granted there are many significant back problems that could be).

If so, Hamilton will have played his last game as a Bull and been a fairly large disappointment overall. He was missed nearly 50% of his games and was never really able to contribute much to the team. Fans, such as myself, have called for his benching most of this season while he did play. The best thing about the Hamilton signing is that it wasn't a Jason Richardson signing.

For all the ripping on the front office for choosing Hamilton, Jason Richardson was among the favorites for Bulls fans to sign, and we'd be on the hook for him for another couple seasons still. Important to remember when playing imaginary GM is that fans typically only live with their decisions in the moment and not the contract long consequences of the bad decisions they would have made.

If the Bulls haven't told Hamilton to stay away they probably should have. An ideal scenario would have been to bring him off the bench just when needed in a small role. Let Belinelli start and play 35 minutes a night, but have Hamilton available for 10-15 minutes here and there as a reserve. He might do well against scrubs that fall for his veteran moves. His low efficiency shooting style may have worked better with a bench lacking any offensive firepower.

That said, I doubt we see Rip back, nor do I think we particularly want to.

Welcome back Malcom Thomas

Thomas officially signed his 10 day contract that was reported a couple of days ago. If you don't remember him, he was a standout in summer league a couple years ago and had a nice preseason. There was some thought he'd have an outside shot of making the team, but there wasn't really room on the roster for him.

He's bounced around as a fringe player with the Spurs and Warriors the past couple of years as well as playing in the D-League. He's only appeared in a few games and hasn't yet had a notable impact in any of them. That said, I'm willing to try five minutes of Malcolm Thomas and see what happens if Taj Gibson remains out.

Good news on the injury front?

Reportedly, Taj Gibson is feeling recovered from his sprained knee and will likely give it ago on Thursday. Kirk Hinrich also was said to have a nice practice and also has an excellent shot to return Thursday.

Nothing's changed with Derrick Rose. His last word is that he's all there physically and just needs to get there mentally. I think you get their mentally by playing in games, and if he's truly all there physically it's ridiculous he's sitting out to get his head straight. You don't cure a phobia by avoiding what you're afraid of, you cure it by exposure. This is common sense.

If he's not there physically, of course, get yourself right. However, Derrick Rose himself says he's there, so at this point Rose is bringing the weak sauce. Hate me all you want for pointing it out. I still love Rose, but he's either not getting his point across clearly about the state of his health, or needs to get back on the court.

Bulls reviewed video to confirm they were screwed by the league

The Bulls went and reviewed every angle of Joakim Noah's final shot and confirmed that no official called goaltending. The call on the floor appears to be a made basket and was only switched to goal tending due to protesting of the Nuggets bench and to allow the review. There's no official who signals goal tending on the shot which makes the review illegal.

It's probably not the most disgraceful call the league has ever made (eh Kings fans?), but it's pretty aggravating one all the same. As I noted though, the impact is more or less negligible. The Bulls just need to not finish eighth and other than that their playoff seeding is mostly irrelevant. The only relevance will be whether or not Rose comes back for the playoffs.

Even then, unless LeBron's knee explodes in a fiery inferno from some unknown side effect of popping steroids and HGH the playoffs aren't going to matter much anyway. No one is beating Miami. I would have taken the Heat over the field early in the season when their competition looked like it might be tougher, now it looks like a joke. Miami's going to walk away with the title this season.


Leave a comment
  • Doug if rose dont come back this season I think fans/media will now have right to question him. If he has declared himself healthy he should play. Not even because the fans want him to but for his teammates that's fighting through injuries and wanting to battle for a championship even tho the odds are against them! I think for the first couple games derrick being on the court will give them an extra boost. anything can happen in playoffs. As weak as the east is bulls can make it to the east con finals with rose. Crazy things happen sometimes so rose shouldn't deny his teammates that chance even if it's a small one.

  • In reply to bullzfan:

    I agree, and I'd agree even if the Bulls were hopelessly out of the playoffs. Rose's job is to play basketball. If he's healthy enough to play, he should play, even if his game isn't 100% yet.

  • In reply to bullzfan:

    If you want to argue Rose should be back because he's healthy that's one thing, but to base his return on his teammates being tired/injuries, team has no depth, Thibs running them all into the ground, and all these other non-Rose related situations is wrong and shouldn't be the reason why he comes back.

  • I've always said making 37 million a year can make ya soft...

  • If the organization is ok with Rose sitting out the rest of the season, who are the fans and media to question this decision???

  • In reply to Reese1:

    So fans aren't entitled to their own opinion?

    The organization seemed ok with trading Boozer for Bargs too even though it would have made it even harder for the Bulls to compete financially going forward. But, since the orgs was ok with it, I guess fans should have been too.

  • In reply to BearDown1982:

    Nope but like you will see below its about the Bulls FO making dumb decisions.

  • In reply to Reese1:

    All the fans that pay a ticket to support bulls and d rose salary. Because he said he s healthy!!!

  • In reply to bullzfan:

    I get that but if the organization is supportive of Rose sitting out than blame the Bulls organization. It's not the first time the Bulls brass has made dumb assed decisions now is it?

  • In reply to Reese1:

    Nope lol

  • Won't be the last time either eh

  • Lost in all the criticism of Rose's decision to delay his return are the multiple horribly botched decisions from last season which returned Rose to play too soon. The turf toe, lower back, groin tear, were all injuries which Rose had not yet recovered from when he was carrying the Bulls team in the playoffs on April 28, 2012.

    Yet someone "medically cleared" Rose to play after all these injuries even though it was OBVIOUS to even casual fans that Rose was not recovered. And remember the game Rose returned from his groin tear injury against the Knicks in MSG on national TV on April 8, 2012? Thibs played Rose 40 minutes his first game back and Rose had to sit the next game.

    The Rose Camp has learned from these mistakes and is taking a more conservative approach with this much more serious (career threatening/altering) ACL injury which was likely caused by Rose playing injured.

    The best time for Rose to return from his ACL rehab is preseason games, then early season games, rounding into All-Star/MVP form by the all star break 2014. These early games are without much pressure and Rose can take his time and play himself into shape.

    If he returned now, Thibs would surely grind Rose and expect Rose to carry the entire team through the playoffs on his surgically repaired ACL You don't think the Rose Camp knows this? That is NOT the intelligent way to return from an ACL injury.

    Bulls have no chance to beat the Heat with this roster. The concern should be with protecting Rose, ensuring he's healthy for the next 5+ seasons, and assembling a competitive roster to support Rose for the future.

  • In reply to Edward:

    Agreed 200%...

  • If you think Amanda`s story is great..., 5 weaks-ago my uncles step-son basically actually earnt $5927 grafting 40 hours a month from there apartment and there best friend's mom`s neighbour did this for seven months and brought in more than $5927 part time at their pc. use the tips from this website... =======bit90.com=======

  • seems like the bulls tried to create interest in rip before the trading deadline. he shot almost every time he touched the ball. after there was no trade interest..... sayonara

  • Anyone see that Kendall Gill was suspended?
    After his broadcast of Bulls vs. Denver, Tim Doyle approached him critically about his perspective on the goaltending call. Kendall threw a punch drawing blood…

  • And Kendall Gill is a semi-pro boxer and martial artist. He really knows how to throw a punch!

Leave a comment