Posted April 18, 12:30 p.m
As blog comments keep rolling in about what happened in Tuesday's Blue Line evacuation, one of the more marked and disturbing remarks is about a rail operator who may have called riders "stupid" for taking matters into their own hands and exiting a train. The comment also apparently was captured on video. Watch the first third of the story and hear it for yourself.
So what's up with that operator? The CTA is in the process of reviewing disciplinary action for the accused employee, according to Rick Harris, president of the union that represents rail operators. I talked to him about the situation to get his reaction as well as to find out what the CTA typically does in situations like these. (The CTA may weigh in later today with their own comment, so stay tuned for an update.)
UPDATE at 1:08 p.m.: That was fast, huh? Here's what the CTA had to say about the investigation into Stupid-gate.
"CTA is conducting a thorough investigation into the Blue Line incident. We did receive some complaints regarding an operator and are investigating those complaints as we would when we receive any type of complaint regarding a CTA employee.
CTA has a progressive disciplinary procedure and should the investigation indicate disciplinary action is warranted, any action taken will follow those procedures and will include consideration of the nature of the violation, and whether or not the operator has previous violations."
Harris, for his part, predicts that it doesn't look good for the operator-gone-wild. He said the "stupid" remark jarred him from his breakfast as he watched the local news, and has met with a lot of media attention.
"I was sitting at my kitchen table watching Channel 7's coverage of the evacuation," Harris told me. "As they are showing video of it, I heard it clearly: 'Hey, stupid, get back on the train.'"
Harris said he has since confirmed it was one of his members, and though he does not condone the behavior, he believes it can be defended.
"This is proof we need the conductors back on the train," Harris said, hearkening back to the two-person train operation that was completely phased out by 2000 due to budgetary constraints. "It's asking a lot for one guy to evacuate an entire train of a 1,000 or more people."
Harris pointed out that in the post-conductor era, the rail operator is charged with checking out a malfunctioning train, communicating with the Control Center and a chorus of CTA managers demanding to know what's going on-- all while trying to keep riders calm. It's a case, Harris said, where anyone could snap.
While I can concede tempers would flare while trapped in a dark subway tunnel, I asked Harris how he would feel if an emergency occurred on an airplane and a flight attendant called passengers "stupid." It would be unacceptable, right?
"That's right," Harris said, but countered there isn't one flight attendant per flight for let's say 200 passengers. In my experience, there are at least three or four, so that's about an attendant for every 50 flyers.
Harris said that the operator could face anywhere from a one- to a 29-day suspension for a behavioral infraction. At worst, such as in the case of it getting physical, an operator can be canned.
But Harris feels "fanfare" and footage of the incident could lead to a firing.
"I think they'll go for the jugular this time," Harris said of the CTA.
Should this rogue rail operator be canned for being stuck on stupid during the Blue LIne evacuation? Or is high-level operator irritation a sign that the CTA needs to rethink its staffing on trains?