Monday, July 21, 2008 -- 11 a.m. -- on my couch
I've been trying out the new PixelSkin case from Speck for the iPhone 3G for a little more than a week now.
Let me start by saying that as someone who prefers a minimal cloth case, knowing full well that I need to take my iPhone out of the case to use it, that the case I've been testing isn't for me.
However, it's a good case if you are someone who's prone to drops and spills.
To put it on, you slide the bottom of your iPhone 3G in thru the screen cutout, then pull the top corners around to front of your phone.
How does one describe the PixelSkin? Here's what the Web site says:
"PixelSkin’s lightweight, form-fit helps protect your iPhone from bumps and scrapes, while the textured tile pattern provides a comfortable, tactile sensation in your hand and a no-slip grip. The case offers openings to all ports, controls and sensors for convenient accessibility."
100 percent true. The rubber bounces back and retains its shape. The front of the iPhone remains open, giving you access to the screen and the switches and the camera.
There's only two things that I don't like as much, regardless of what kind of case I like.
First off, if I drop it back side down, I think it might bounce. I feel like my iPhone will be incredibly sturdy and safe in that scenario. However, if I drop it face down, I think I'm in trouble. The completely open front, while providing great access, doesn't really do much to protect it.
Second, it's builky and therefore a little tough to get it to fit comfortably in my pocket. It fits, but it's not as easy to fit. While you'd think that could be said for any case, the one I use doesn't add any additional bulk to the package, however, my iPhone isn't likely to survive a fall.
So there's always trade offs.
Here's some more info from the Web site.
-- Soft-touch tiled pattern offers added comfort and grip (true true).
-- Lightweight design protects without adding bulk (sorry, but this isn't entirely true. Not a giant amount of bulk, but it adds some).
-- No fussy, smudgy screen protectors to get in your way (true, but no protection up front either)
-- Available in 7 tasty colors! (vibrant, actually -- I've got a black and white one here and I really like the colors). The full color line is Licorice Black, Spearmint Green, Sherbet Pink, Huckelberry Purple, Marshmallow White, Corncob Yellow, Blueberry Blue.
At 2.5 inches in length, 0.5 inches in width, 4.75 inches in height and 4.0 ounces in weight, the PixelSkin case for iPhone 3G is good. I just don't think it's great.
You can find all the information and decide for yourself here.
PROS: Vibrant colors, easy access to ports, strong rubbery grip holds iPhone 3G in place
CONS: A little thick, lack of protection on front of screen
RATING: 3 out of 5 iPhones
Thanks for calling.