Different Spokes

« Number 1004 of things you don't A good experience with accessiblity in »

The media's struggle with disabilities

user-pic
Daniel

Restaurants, airlines, and other companies tend to struggle when it comes to dealing with a person with a disability. But one line of work we haven't touched on yet is the media. And believe me, despite working in the journalism field, the media is not exempt from my disdain!

There are three phrases found in almost every article about a person with a disability. And each of these statements drives me up the wall. Let's examine them individually:

"Suffers from...": As in, "Daniel suffers from Spina bifida." Another example can be found in this article that popped up on my Google news a few weeks ago. Let's see...I enjoy watching sports all day, go on long walks/wheels when the weather is nice, and hold down a nice job. Am I really suffering? In the article I linked to, 9-year-old Kaitlin is a member of the cheer leading team. Is she really suffering?

To me, suffering is a mindset. So if somebody truly is suffering from a debilitating disease, a journalist has every right to convey that. However, when it's used in every article about every person with a disability, the phrase loses all relative meaning and becomes practically useless.

"Confined to a wheelchair":
When a kid asks me "How do I sleep?" I can shrug that off and laugh about it. But when an adult assumes that I'm sitting here all day, and can't get out of my chair, I want to cry about it. Seriously, I'm sitting here "stuck" in my chair all day? Not only that, but the only other time I ever see the media use the phrase "confined" comes when they talk about a prisoner being in "solitary confinement." Are they comparing a person in a wheelchair to a prisoner? If so, we have bigger problems than even I thought. This leads me to the final phrase...

"Wheelchair-bound":
To me, this is another lazy way for journalists to tell the reader that we, in fact, use a wheelchair! It's not hard to say, "Daniel uses a wheelchair for mobility." I understand space limits, and know that "wheelchair-bound" is two words while my example is a whopping six words. But if it means we can help shatter an incorrect stereotype, I'd like to think that a reporter can spare four words somewhere else.

It is easy to focus my anger on the journalists themselves. However, to me, this issue is much broader and begins at the very roots of the journalism tree. I went through a 4-year, intensive journalism program at one of the top journalism schools in the nation and they never once mentioned how to describe an individual with a disability. How are journalists supposed to understand that these phrases are not only hurtful, but inaccurate, if they are never taught otherwise? Therefore, only once we re-educate our current journalists and pass these messages along to the next generation will we begin to see the necessary changes in the media's treatment of those with disabilities.

Recommended

[?]

Recent Posts

Subscribe

Leave a comment

4 Comments

Shark7 said:

default userpic local-auth auth-type-mt

I appreciate "The media's struggle with disabilities" article from 06/03/10. The AP Stylebook and Libel Manual, correctly addresses disability related terminology, including the proper wording for a person that uses a wheelchair--wheelchair-user.

chris said:

default userpic local-auth auth-type-mt

thanks for sharing this. Sometimes i hear people use the term "differently abled." for some reason it makes me cringe, but i can't identify why. Do you have any thoughts on this term?

Daniel said:

user-pic

Chris,

I can definitely understand your hesitation with "differently abled." While it's borne out of good intentions, it has an aura to it of society trying to be too politically correct and tell everybody that they're "ok." Instead of using a cheesy phrase, people can just show us acceptance through their actions!

anneelizabeth said:

default userpic local-auth auth-type-mt

I love how you wrote about this. For my media and culture class I recently made a vlog about how disabilities are shown in mainstream media. Check it out!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcPB6_ZIJ3k&feature=player_embedded

Leave a Comment?

Some HTML is permitted: a, strong, em

What your comment will look like:

said:

what will you say?

Most Active Pages Right Now

ChicagoNow.com on Facebook