Blackhawks Confidential

Hall of Fame Archives

Trio of former Blackhawks top week of NHL news

ed-belfour_2.jpg

One's leaving the game.  Another is back in the game.  And a third wants to return.  Most of the limited NHL ink spent this past week in the slow month of August has focused on three ex-Hawks - Jeremy Roenick, Ed Belfour and Theo Fleury.

Yep, I said Theo Fleury.  More on that in a moment.

Roenick's decision to retire has led to the inevitable discussions regarding his legacy and Hall of Fame credentials.  I am a biased observer on the subject as Roenick is my favorite Blackhawk player of the past twenty years.  JR skating to the bench with his broken teeth on his tongue says it all.  You can never say that the guy didn't leave it all on the ice.

Yahoo's Ross McKeon makes the argument that Roenick deserves election to the Hall by comparing him to the already elected Pat LaFontaine.  Others, including myself, are not so sure.  JR is a fringe Hall-of-Famer based on numbers alone.  It will provide a good debate when Roenick becomes eligible for enshrinment in 2012.

Continue reading...

Brett Hull should be Blackhawks Hall of Famer

If life was fair and reasonable, Brett Hull should be going into the Hall of Fame in a Blackhawks uniform.

It made all the sense in the world that Bill Wirtz should have done whatever it took in the late 1980s, when Calgary traded Hull to St. Louis, to find a way to add a valuable asset to his offense, not to the mention the son of Bobby Hull.

You don't need to be a marketing genius like John McDonough to understand what Brett could have meant as an attendance draw. The club probably would have soared to heights beyond the 1992 Stanley Cup finals loss to Pittsburgh with a viable attack for years.

But Bill and Bobby were sworn enemies. Bobby and Brett were sometimes at odds. And Mike Keenan and Brett would have been an odd couple, although their big-bang pairing might have created a whole new world for hockey in Chicago.

It was a dysfunctional family all the way around.

Losing out to backwater St. Louis on any terms shouldn't be an alternative for a Chicago sports team. But tell that to Cubs fans.

The Hulls themselves would have welcomed the chance to be in the Hall wearing the Indian on their sweaters. If Bill and Bobby had sought ways to co-exist rather than be conflicting egos, how much easier it would have been to welcome Brett to the family when he was looking for a hockey home.

I remember Brett telling me he was intrigued by the idea of playing in Chicago. My suggestion in a Tribune story that the Hawks out-bid the Blues in free agency sent St. Louis general manager Ron Caron into a rage, although he should have known not to expect the unexpected in Chicago.

Wirtz didn't like mavericks, be they named Bobby, Brett or Jeremy Roenick. Here's hoping the new-fashioned Hawks bring back old-fashioned maverick Chris Chelios, who's only famous now for not knowing when to quit.

That's still a valuable quality to add to any dressing room. 

 

Most Active Pages Right Now

ChicagoNow.com on Facebook