Justin's versus Theo Peanut Butter Cups: Gluten-Free Taste Test

Ladies and gentleman, start your peanut butter cups!

These are not your average Reese's peanut butter cups too. I am so over those years ago. I am now into the big leagues.

We are talking about Theo Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups and Justin's Peanut Butter Cups - two organic brands that you can find at your local Whole Foods.  I prefer my chocolate to be at a more higher quality, taste very good and come from a more organic source. I have the same higher standards when it comes to my peanut butter too.

In one corner, I have Justin's peanut butter cups. I have been eating these peanut butter cups for quite a long time.  I prefer to eat the dark chocolate cup over the milk chocolate cups. The dark chocolate peanut cups are much better in quality than Reese's by a long shot. The chocolate is a higher quality.  Since their focus in on the peanut butter and other nut better spreads, the quality is absolutely simply awesome. The peanut butter filling is smooth and creamy as it melts in your mouth.

In other corner, I have Theo Chocolate Peanut Butter cups, which comes in milk and dark chocolate. They are new to the peanut butter cup kingdom, but have always had excellent chocolate. They claim to the first Fair Trade Peanut Butter cups. but Justin's has been fair trade for as long as I ate them. These cups are palm and soy free, vegan, gluten free, and kosher. The print on the package was colorful as I have known their products to be.

When I opened the packaging to eat the peanut butter cups, they were not individually encased in a paper wrapper, which was different than I was used to.  Justin's has their peanut butter cups wrapped individually in the packaging which is good and my preference. I have had a few times this summer where I left my precious cups near the sun and the chocolate. Let's just say that the refrigerator saved the day and allowed to eat them in my big block. 'Nuf said!

It took a bite out of the first peanut butter cup from Theo and found the peanut butter had a similar quality. The peanut butter was of excellent quality, but missed the creaminess compared to Justin's.  On the other hand, the quality of the chocolate was very well done since that is their speciality.

Overall, I think both companies did very well with their peanut butter cups, but I still think Justin's is the best and came up on top.

Justin's is the winner of this peanut butter cup taste test.

Leave a comment

  • Advertisement:
  • Advertisement:
  • ChicagoNow is full of win

    Welcome to ChicagoNow.

    Meet our bloggers,
    post comments, or
    pitch your blog idea.

  • Meet The Blogger


    Greetings, Chicago Suburbanites! Welcome to Active Suburbia! My name is Denise, but I am known as Firefly, Red, and "Hey there". I will be your tour guide to everything active within the Chicago suburbs. In this blog, I will be your guide to places within the Chicagoland Suburbs that will help lead a more active lifestyle and a lot of fun too. In fact, studies have shown that reading this blog will bring a smile on your face, a spring in your step, and burn those last nasty 5 lbs that you can't get off. (Ok, everything's true except for the last one that hasn't been proved.....YET, but I am determined to make it true.) Here's a short introduction about myself: I am a very active person. You can say that I have endurance, determination, grit, and hard work in my bones. I enjoy running and cycling. I have completed a couple of marathons, half-marathons, 5K's, etc in my running career. I also enjoy trying most things active and willing to explore if I have to. I enjoy checking out the trails near me and doing a lot of running. I also enjoy teaching Pilates and yoga. I am also a suburbanite living in the awesome suburb of Berwyn. I am a suburban girl at heart and love every minute of it. I originally grew up in the frozen tundra of the Twin Cities. I am also a die-hard sports fan and enjoy the competitive nature of it. I love baseball, college and professional football, and even hockey. I am always interested in finding more fun places within the Chicago suburbs. If you know of a gem, shoot me an e-mail at activesuburbia@gmail.com. You can also follow me on Twitter too.

  • Categories

  • Need sleep the natural way? Click on the audio sample.

  • Have you tried iPage?

  • Is your life getting toxic? Click on the link below

  • Need sleep naturally?

  • Recent posts

  • Monthly Archives

  • Latest on ChicagoNow

  • Advertisement: